With less than a week to go before the November 3rd election, here’s a quick update on Issue 2.
Some noteworthy news articles:
- NO on Issue 2 – Toledo Blade, 10/28/09
“Regardless of how anyone feels about the treatment of farm animals, Issue 2 is poor public policy, and it should be defeated.
The Ohio Constitution should never be used to promote the interests of specific individuals, businesses, or industries. The reasonable approach to balancing the needs of Ohio’s farming industry and the concerns of animal-rights groups would have been to follow Michigan’s example and work out a compromise in state law that would protect both farmers and farm animals.”
- Livestock care is key in Issue 2 debate – Columbus Dispatch, 10/25/09
In case there’s any doubt about this being big business, consider Ohio’s 2008 agriculture numbers:
• 4 million pigs were raised on 4,000 farms. Another 170,000 sows were used for breeding.
• 27 million hens laid 7.1 billion eggs. There were 57.5 million chickens and 6 million turkeys raised for meat.
• 1.2 million beef cattle came from 15,000 farms. Another 700,000 calves were marketed for veal. - Controversial proposal is battle over who regulates agriculture industry – Dayton Daily News, 10/25/09
While the Ohio Constitution authorizes a state board of education, boards typically aren’t prescribed in that document, said Charles Hallinan, a University of Dayton law professor and constitutional scholar.
“It’s an oddity,” Hallinan said of Issue 2. “It is unusual enough that it would give me pause to include it in the constitution.”
- Issue 2 Spending – Columbus Dispatch, 10/23/09
Backers of state Issue 2, the proposed constitutional amendment to create the Ohio Livestock Care Standards Board, gave more than $4 million to that cause.
“Contributions to Issue 2 are about much more than just supporting a ballot measure,” said Jack Fisher, executive vice president of the Ohio Farm Bureau Federation and treasurer of Ohioans for Livestock Care Political Action Committee.
“They are really an investment in educating all Ohioans on farmers’ commitment to excellent animal care and to providing safe, affordable, locally grown food for our consumers.”
Issue 2 supporters said about $3 million of the total came from Ohio family farmers and groups representing farm organizations.
Records show about $1.2 million came via more than 100 donations from out-of-state organizations, ranging from the Delaware Farm Bureau to the Arizona Pork Council to the Texas Turkey Federation to the Hawaii Cattlemen’s Council. Eli Lily Co. of Indianapolis added $25,000.
The drive to pass state Issue 2 was led by a dozen six-figure donations. The Ohio Farm Bureau chipped in about $535,000 overall, although the largest single contribution, $200,000, came from United Egg Producers in Alpharetta, Ga.
- Justice calls State Issue 2 misuse of constitution – Columbus Dispatch, 10/20/09
O’Connor said the state constitution is a “much bigger document” that should not be amended to include policy decisions, such as livestock care, that are best left to lawmakers.
O’Connor, who plans to run for chief justice next year, said backers of Issue 2 understand that once something is added to the constitution, it will take “an arm and a leg” to overturn it, the paper reported.
The most recent list of groups who officially oppose Issue 2 (I’m sure I’m missing some):
- American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA)
- Capital Area Humane Society
- Center for Food Safety
- Cleveland Animal Protective League
- Clintonville Community Market
- Coalition to Ban Ohio Dog Auctions
- Columbus Top Dogs
- Cornucopia Institute
- Family Farm Defenders
- Farm Sanctuary
- Food & Water Watch
- Geauga Humane Society
- Grand Lake St. Mary’s Improvement Association
- Humane Society of the United States
- League of Humane Voters of Ohio
- League of Women Voters of Ohio
- Libertarian Party of Ohio
- Local Matters
- Mercy for Animals
- Ohio Conference on Fair Trade
- Ohio Connections to Whole Food and Nutritional Healing
- Ohio Ecological Food and Farming Association
- The Ohio Environmental Stewardship Alliance
- Ohio Environmental Council
- Ohio Farmers Union
- Ohio Freedom Alliance
- Ohio Sierra Club
- Organic Consumers Association
- Progress Ohio
- The Wellness Forum
- Toledo Area Humane Society
- Western Lake Erie Water Keepers Association
- Weston A. Price Foundation
- Williams County Alliance
- Wood County Citizens Opposed to Factory Farms
- Working Families Win – Ohio Chapter






